Sara McDonnell • August 14, 2024

Edenhope hosts The Great Debate: Are men really from Mars?


Edenhope will be at the centre of a debate for the ages, finally answering the question: Are Men from Mars and Women from Venus … or is that just an excuse? 

‘The Great Debate’, hosted by Grampians Health Edenhope, will see three men and three women untangle the baffling, infuriating and often comical customs of the opposite sex. 

 

Do men really lack the gene to fold clothes and change nappies? Do women’s brains process maps back-to-front? And, what is the true cause of man flu? 

 

All of life’s quandaries will be mined in the light-hearted exploration of gender and heterosexual relationships. 

 

“It’s going to be a laugh, but we all know these conversations tend to uncover some home truths,” social worker June Spencer said. 

 

“Whether we are fundamentally different or not, there are patterns in relationships that don’t do either party any good. 

 

“By holding a mirror up to ourselves – even if it’s one of those fun house mirrors – we can all stop and reflect on our differences and maybe re-frame our partners in a new light.” 

 

In the midst of a tough farming season, Ms Spencer said communication and support between partners was essential. 

 

“Stress can bring out the worst in all of us and it’s easy to shut-down and forget that our partners are dealing with their own inner struggles,” she said. 

 

“When the farmers are suffering, the whole community suffers, and the effects of that often show up in the home. 

 

“We hope this event will bring the community together for a laugh, but also open the door to better communication and personal reflection.” 

 

Ms Spencer (henceforth known as 'Judge Juney') will keep the speakers in line but audience members will cast their votes to put an historical end to the great debate. 

 

Neither team would reveal their arguments, but they did promise props and hinted at some audience bribery. 

 

Edenhope Lions Club has funded venue hire and finger food for the free event, which will be staged at 7pm on Friday August 23, at Edenhope Golf Club.

30 July 2025
The arrival of a new accessible bus, equipped with a wheelchair lift, is opening up a world of adventure for Edenhope residents.
By Sara McDonnell 8 July 2025
A familiar face has joined the Social Support Day Centre program, with Fred Carberry officially coming out of retirement.
By Sara McDonnell 30 June 2025
When Grampians Health community health nurse Cath McDonald started planning a half-marathon event for Edenhope, she was targeting people like Kirily Ryan.
By Sara McDonnell 17 June 2025
More than 200 people attended Grampians Health Edenhope’s Cultural Fusion event, to celebrate diversity.
By Sara McDonnell 10 June 2025
Whether you are filling up your car in Edenhope, ordering a bite to eat, picking up a script, attending a Council meeting, stocking up at the supermarket or getting a blood test at the hospital – you’re likely interacting with a migrant, with a fascinating back-story.
By Sara McDonnell 2 June 2025
Molly Pretlove spent years in the city, and travelling across Europe, but the pull from rural Victoria never really faded.
By Sara McDonnell 26 May 2025
Satnam and Nishu Jayee are used to life in the fast lane.
By Sara McDonnell 26 May 2025
A solo pirate mission, from Edenhope’s Marg Warren, has raised $772 for kids’ brain cancer research.
By Sara McDonnell 20 May 2025
Kath Atwell has intimate knowledge of the pain and all-consuming responsibility involved with caring for someone with dementia.
By Sara McDonnell 12 May 2025
Most of us have been touched by the cruelty of cancer, but few more so than Marg Warren.